\

Ask HN: Should Uber Ratings Decay over Time?

10 points - yesterday at 10:32 PM


I’ve been thinking about how platforms like Uber calculate reputation scores, and I believe there’s a fundamental flaw in how historical ratings are treated.

Uber calculates passenger ratings using the last 500 rated trips, regardless of when those trips occurred.

In my case, I have 455 ratings, 426 of which are five stars (93.6%). My overall rating is 4.86.

What bothers me isn’t the score itself, but the underlying methodology.

A negative rating from five years ago can carry exactly the same weight as one received yesterday. And if you’re an infrequent user who hasn’t accumulated 500 ratings, that negative feedback could influence your reputation for years.

This raises an interesting question: Should reputation systems measure your historical average, or should they attempt to represent who you are today?

One possible solution is exponential time decay:

Weight = 2^(-t/H)

Where t is the age of the rating and H is a half-life, perhaps 12 months.

Under that approach, a rating from one year ago would carry 50% of its original weight, and one from two years ago just 25%.

Of course, this introduces other challenges. How do you prevent someone with a history of poor behaviour from simply waiting for their reputation to recover? How do you maintain statistical confidence for infrequent users? Would Bayesian smoothing or a minimum effective sample size help?

There’s also a broader philosophical question around the right to be forgotten. Should digital reputation systems indefinitely preserve the consequences of historical assessments, particularly when those assessments are subjective and potentially no longer representative?

I’m curious how others would approach this.

* Is a rolling window of 500 ratings statistically defensible without considering time? * Would exponential decay produce a fairer and more predictive reputation score? * Should platforms expose both a lifetime rating and a recent-behaviour rating? * Are there better approaches already being used in other reputation systems?

I’d be particularly interested in perspectives from people who’ve worked on marketplace ranking, trust and safety, or reputation algorithms.

It seems like a relatively simple mathematical change, but one with potentially significant implications for fairness across digital platforms.

  • scrivna

    today at 2:28 AM

    Yeah I agree, I bake more recent reviews too. Another example would be on Amazon where they tell were bought in the last 30 days. I find that useful to gauge recent popularity

    • onel

      today at 1:09 PM

      That is true and the same should supply for things like restaurants. There's no guarantee that you're going to get the quality of service or food that you got 2-3 years ago.

      The exceptions might be physical products? If the same version is sold for many years then reviews should not degrade. But now as physical products are so tired of software, the experience is also tied to that specific software version.

      • what

        today at 1:37 AM

        Why are drivers rating passengers in the first place?

          • phil21

            today at 2:12 AM

            For anti-social behavior, much like passengers rating drivers.

            Of course both of these can be abused. Uber has done a mediocre (at best) job of policing this behavior on both sides.

              • what

                today at 6:23 AM

                Anti social behavior should simply be reported so they can be banned from the service. I would bet passenger ratings are largely based on whether your tip is considered acceptable.

        • samratkar

          today at 4:30 AM

          [flagged]

          • Theophane_Rame

            today at 1:30 AM

            [flagged]