aurareturn
today at 7:49 AM
By the way, this is the same argument that Michael Burry used to short Nvidia.
He claims that GPU depreciation/obsoletion is much faster than hyperscalers are assuming because new chips will be much better. He's being proved wrong right now because H200 rental prices have been claiming for the last 8 month despite B200 having 10-20x better inference efficiency.[0]
The logic is fundamentally flawed in my opinion. Let's use future Nvidia chips being much better optimized for LLMs for example.
New Nvidia chips 10x better than H200 --> data centers buy a lot --> Nvidia profits a lot.
New Nvidia chips 10x better than H200 --> data centers don't buy --> no faster than expected obsoletion.
In other words, the very act of buying many new Nvidia GPUs would be the event that causes faster than expected obsoletion. Yet, if you don't buy those new Nvidia GPUs, then there is no faster than expected obsoletion.
We also live in a world where there is competition. If Amazon doesn't buy but Microsoft does, suddenly Microsoft can offer better $/token prices.
[0]https://inferencex.semianalysis.com/inference
1. The same isn’t necessarily true of the rest of the hardware stack which may be reused between accelerator generations.
2. You’re missing the “New Nvidia chips 10x B200, compute requirement grows less than 10*software improvements YoY -> buy less Nvidia.” Valuations are based on forward projections (>1T annual for NVDA) which can be revised down leading to a drop in valuation.
> If Amazon doesn't buy but Microsoft does
The big 3 all have their own proprietary accelerators. Meta is buying TPUs as well for now.
I would bet Nvidia’s major customers in 2 years are neoclouds and it seems that Jensen is making the same bet.
aurareturn
today at 11:24 AM
1. So this makes Burry’s argument even less convincing since those auxiliary hardware can last longer.
2. Jevons Paradox. More efficiency should lead to bigger models, faster inference, and more total tokens.
3. By all accounts, Trainium and Maia and Meta’s internal chip are struggling to keep up with Nvidia. That’s why they order as many Nvidia chips as possible. They’re not giving up but it isn’t as easy as buying stock Arm cores and taking them to TSMC.
Neoclouds may very well be Nvidia’s biggest customers and this probably what Nvidia wants.