The problem with models like this is they're built on very little actual training data we can trace back to verifiable protein data. The protein data back, and other sources of training data for stuff like this, has a lot of broken structures in them and "creative liberties" taken to infer a structure from instrument data. It's a very complex process that leaves a lot for interpretation.

On top of that, we don't have a clear understanding on how certain positions (conformations) of a structure affect underlying biological mechanisms.

Yes, these models can predict surprisingly accurate structures and sequences. Do we know if these outputs are biologically useful? Not quite.

This technology is amazing, don't get me wrong, but to the average person they might see this and wonder why we can't go full futurism and solve every pathology with models like these.

We've come a long way, but there's still a very very long way to go.

• stardust2

  yesterday at 9:17 PM

  How do we get more verifiable protein data? So even if we had better data, we don't yet understand how the structure impacts the biology?

full article: https://huggingface.co/blog/OpenMed/training-mrna-models-25-...

• pfisherman

  yesterday at 8:11 PM

  Nice work! Here is an article you may find helpful if you have not already come across it.[0]. You may also want to consider benchmarking against some non ML methods.[1]

  0. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35318324/

  1. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06127-z

• xyz100

  yesterday at 3:18 PM

  What makes this dataset or problem worth solving compared to other health datasets? Would the results on this task be broadly useful to health?

  • CyberDildonics

    yesterday at 4:44 PM

    What other "datasets" are you talking about? How do you "solve a dataset" ?

HN's blindspots never cease to amaze me.

I am a structural biologist working in pharmaceutical design and this type of thing could be wildly useful (if it works).

Can someone explain what one might use this model for? As a developer with a casual interest in biology it would be fun to play with but honestly not sure what I would do

• colechristensen

  yesterday at 4:25 PM

  You can get your feet wet with genetic engineering for surprisingly little money.

  This guy shows a lot of how it's done: https://www.youtube.com/@thethoughtemporium

  Basically you can design/edit/inject custom genes into things and see real results spending on the scale of $100-$1000.

  • someuser54541

    yesterday at 4:40 PM

    Is there something like this in text/readable format?

  • _zoltan_

    yesterday at 7:12 PM

    My main concern is using fungi. If it ends up in my lungs I'm most likely screwed, right?

    • colechristensen

      yesterday at 8:20 PM

      This is the classic meme https://www.reddit.com/r/labrats/comments/mmv2ig/lab_strains...

      Lab strains of things tend to be extremely sensitive and not human adapted. You shouldn't study and modify human-infecting organisms in your basement anyway. While you shouldn't ignore protective equipment and proper procedure... paranoia about infecting yourself with a lab leak isn't warranted.

    • nurettin

      yesterday at 8:02 PM

      Yes, but most students produce their best work while infected.

> In Progress: CodonJEPA

JEPA is going to break the whole industry :D

• digdugdirk

  yesterday at 3:50 PM

  Can you explain this? I haven't heard of JEPA, and from a quick search it seems to be vision/robotics based?

  • khalic

    yesterday at 4:42 PM

    It’s a self supervised learning architecture, and it’s pretty much universal. The loss function runs on embeddings, and some other smart architectural choices allover. Worth diving into for a few hours, Yann LeCun gives some interesting talks about it

  • lukeinator42

    yesterday at 3:51 PM

    https://openreview.net/pdf?id=BZ5a1r-kVsf

What makes these Domain specific models work when we don’t have good domain models for health care, chemistry, economics and so on

• colechristensen

  yesterday at 4:26 PM

  >we don’t have good domain models for health care, chemistry, economics and so on

  Who says we don't?

  • simianwords

    yesterday at 4:38 PM

    Examples please?

    • colechristensen

      yesterday at 5:13 PM

      No, it's really simple to search for domain specific models being used "in production" all over the place

      • simianwords

        yesterday at 5:16 PM

        I didn’t find a single one that outperforms a general model.

        • colechristensen

          yesterday at 5:56 PM

          Ok, alphafold.

          • simianwords

            yesterday at 6:01 PM

            It’s not a large language model

Distributing the load on this will probably be infinitely more useful than “folding at home”

gray goo of the future

hmmmm seems like some fake hype.